The All American American Jack Swagger met ECW Champion Christian at Judgment Day 2009. Jack Swagger well concentrated on Christian and successfully handled Christian with his powerful power game. Jack Swagger continued his domination and seriously injured him with same power game plan. However, Christian surprised Jack Swagger by eliminating to outside of the ring and injured with high fly move but Jack Swagger quickly recovered from injuries and surprised ECW Champion Christian with his domination again.

In this match, Jack Swagger damaged stomach area of Christian by throwing over steel ring pole. Jack Swagger continued his domination as well as destruction. However, ECW Champion tried to use every mistake of Jack Swagger. Similarly, Christian continued his intelligent game but Jack Swagger destroyed Christian with Superplex. Jack Swagger tried to defeat Christian with cheap pin fall but match referee rejected his pin fall. Just like Jack Swagger, Christian used same cheap trick and defeated him through pin fall. Christian once again retained his ECW Championship in this pay per view.