Finlay faced ECW Champion Jack Swagger at wrestling pay per view No Way Out 2009 for ECW Championship. Hornswoggle also appeared to this wrestling match with his father Finlay. Finlay tried to give good starting to this wrestling match with his wrestling performance. Finlay damaged knee of Jack Swagger and increased pressure on his knee.

Finlay injured himself with corner of the ring. Similarly, Jack Swagger damaged shoulder of Jack Swagger by throwing towards steel ring pole. Later, Jack Swagger tried to damage Finlay’s injured shoulder. Jack Swagger also damaged his shoulder with shoulder breaker. Jack Swagger increased pressure on his shoulder. However, Finlay surprised ECW Champion Jack Swagger with neck breaker.

ECW Champion Jack Swagger and Finlay go top rope. Finlay gave uppercuts to Jack Swagger. Finlay jumped over Jack Swagger. Hornswoggle watches this wrestling match anxiously. Finlay injured stomach area of Jack Swagger with shoulder blocks. Finlay accidentally injured Hornswoggle. Jack Swagger used this advantage and destroyed Finlay with power bomb. Jack Swagger successfully retained his ECW Championship by defeating Finlay through pin fall.