Tyler Reks faced Sheamus at WWE Superstars on October 1, 2009. Sheamus gave good starting to this wrestling match. Similarly, Tyler Reks also gave good starting to this match by controlling Sheamus. Tyler Reks pushed Sheamus and Sheamus slapped Tyler Reks. Tyler Reks seriously considered and handled Sheamus with hand punches and drop kick. Sheamus went to outside of the ring. Sheamus kicked into his stomach area.

Sheamus damaged stomach area of Tyler Reks. Tyler Reks applied pressure on neck of Tyler Reks. Sheamus dropped his knee on his stomach. Sheamus further damaged his stomach with shoulder block. Tyler Reks kicked on his head and then drop kicked. Tyler Reks gave elbow kicks to Sheamus. Tyler Reks dropped his elbow. Sheamus gave a powerful boot shot on face of Tyler Reks. Sheamus successfully defeated Tyler Reks through pin fall. Sheamus celebrated his victory with wrestling fans.