Mr. Money In the Bank CM Punk appeared at Judgment Day 2009 to face Umaga in one on one wrestling match. CM Punk received excellent response because Chicago is his home town. Umaga looks very powerful in this match. CM Punk tried to dominate Umaga with his mixed martial arts performance and also played intelligent game in order to give good starting to this match. However, Umaga successfully handled CM Punk with his powerful game. Umaga damaged back and left shoulder of CM Punk. Similarly, Umaga damaged his shoulder with steel ring pole. Umaga continued his domination with his powerful performance. Umaga injured CM Punk by dropping his body twice but CM Punk kicked Umaga for his third drop.

CM Punk made a mistake by lifting Umaga but unable to handle his weight. CM Punk tried to control Umaga in several ways but Samoan Bulldozer dominated CM Punk. Umaga made a mistake by jumping from top rope to give a headbutt but CM Punk escaped intelligently. CM Punk took risk and injured Umaga but putting his body on the line. Umaga made a mistake by hitting ring pole and also hits back with one corner. CM Punk tried to give Go to Sleep but Umaga destroyed him with Samoan drop. Once again CM Punk tried Go to Sleep but Umaga seriously destroyed CM Punk and won this match with powerful game. Umaga felt very happy and returned to backstage.